The Magpie Bakery - BLOOMINGDALE, NJ 07403 (Menu & Order Online)

Thanksgiving Pre Order Pies & Desserts

Pre-ordering for our delicious Thanksgiving pies is now open! While you're at it, feel free to add any other goodies you fancy, so everything is ready for you to pick up. Pick up will be in-store on Wednesday, November 27th, but if you're planning to travel and need to collect your order on Tuesday, November 26th, just let us know! The Magpie Bakery is located in Riverside Square, Bloomingdale, and we'll be open from 7am to 7pm. If your preferred pickup date isn't listed, simply leave the date and time in the order note. Thank you! Looking forward to making your Thanksgiving sweet and stress-free!

Pie, Apple Crumb Large 9" (Thanksgiving)

Savor the comforting flavors of our Apple Crumb Large 9” Pie, perfect for your Thanksgiving feast!

Pie, Apple Blueberry Crumb 9" (Thanksgiving)

This 9-inch pie is a delightful blend of juicy apples and sweet blueberries, topped with a crunchy crumb topping.

Pie, Classic Apple 9" (Thanksgiving Size)

Experience our Classic Apple Pie, a 9” treat filled with tender spiced apples and a flaky, buttery crust. Perfect for Thanksgiving!

Classic Cherry Pie 9" (Thanksgiving)

Treat your taste buds to our Classic Cherry Pie, a timeless favorite that's perfect for any festive gathering!

Pie, Cherry Crumb 9" (Thanksgiving)

Enjoy our Cherry Crumb Pie, a 9” Thanksgiving delight. Juicy cherries and a golden, crumbly topping make it the perfect festive treat!

Pie, Blueberry Large 9" (Thanksgiving)

Savor our Blueberry Large 9" Pie, a Thanksgiving favorite filled with juicy blueberries and a perfectly flaky crust. Ideal for your holiday feast!

Pie, Pumpkin 9" (Thanksgiving)

Celebrate with our Pumpkin Pie, a 9” Thanksgiving classic. Silky, spiced pumpkin filling in a flaky crust makes this a holiday essential!

Pie, Chocolate Maple Pecan 9" (Thanksgiving)

Indulge in our Chocolate Maple Pecan Pie, a 9" Thanksgiving delight. Rich chocolate and maple combined with crunchy pecans in a flaky crust make this pie a festive favorite!

Pie, Coconut Custard Cream 9" (Thanksgiving)

Delight in our Coconut Custard Cream Pie, a 9” Thanksgiving treat. Creamy, dreamy coconut custard in a flaky crust, perfect for your holiday table!

Pie, Cream Pie Chocolate Large 9" (Thanksgiving)

Savor our Chocolate Cream Pie, a 9" Thanksgiving indulgence. Rich, creamy chocolate filling in a flaky crust makes this pie a holiday must-have!

Pie, Cream Pie Banana Large 9" (Thanksgiving)

Treat yourself to our Banana Cream Pie, a 9" Thanksgiving delight. Creamy banana filling in a flaky crust makes this pie a holiday favorite!

Cheesecake 8" (Thanksgiving)

Delight your holiday guests with our Thanksgiving Cheesecake, an 8" masterpiece that's perfect for any festive gathering!

Cheesecake 8" With Topping, please specify. (Thankgiving)

Enjoy our 8" Cheesecake topped with your choice of flavors. Perfect for Thanksgiving, this creamy delight can be customized to suit your taste—just specify your desired topping!

Gluten Free Apple Crisp, 8" Square (Thanksgiving)

Indulge in our Gluten-Free Apple Crisp, an 8" square treat perfect for Thanksgiving. Made with tender, spiced apples and a crisp, buttery topping, this dessert offers all the comforting flavors of fall without the gluten. Ideal for sharing with family and friends!

Gluten Free Brownie Tray, 8" Square (Thanksgiving)

Satisfy your sweet tooth with our Gluten-Free Brownie Tray, an 8" square treat perfect for Thanksgiving. Rich and fudgy, these brownies are a delightful indulgence for everyone, even those with gluten sensitivities.

Cookie Platter, 1 Dozen. (Thanksgiving)

This artisanal cookie platter includes a selection of four flavors, chosen from options like Chocolate Nonpareil, Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Cute Sugar Cookies, Maple Pecan Chocolate Chip, Italian Almond, and Italian Rainbow Cookies. Beautifully presented, this platter can be customized to exclude cookies with tree nuts upon request. We are a peanut free facility.

Cookie Platter, Thanksgiving (2 Dozen)

This artisanal cookie platter includes a selection of four flavors, chosen from options like Chocolate Nonpareil, Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Cute Sugar Cookies, Maple Pecan Chocolate Chip, Italian Almond, and Italian Rainbow Cookies. Beautifully presented, this platter can be customized to exclude cookies with tree nuts upon request. We are a peanut free facility.

Assorted Mini Pastry Platter, 2 Dozen (Thanksgiving)

Indulge in our beautifully presented mini pastry assortment, perfect for any occasion! This delightful selection features: Chocolate Croissants Caramel Apple Pastries Cinnamon Rolls Butter Croissants Each pastry is crafted with love and care, offering a variety of flavors and textures that are sure to satisfy every palate. Need something different? Substitutions with our scrumptious bars or brownies are available upon request.

Assorted Mini Pastry Platter, 1 Dozen (Thanksgiving)

Indulge in our beautifully presented mini pastry assortment, perfect for any occasion! This delightful selection features: Chocolate Croissants Caramel Apple Pastries Cinnamon Rolls Butter Croissants Each pastry is crafted with love and care, offering a variety of flavors and textures that are sure to satisfy every palate. Need something different? Substitutions with our scrumptious bars or brownies are available upon request.

Magpie Muffin 6 Pack (Thanksgiving)

Treat yourself to our Magpie Muffin 4 Pack, perfect for Thanksgiving. Each muffin is moist, flavorful, and ideal for adding a touch of holiday sweetness to your celebration!

Gluten Free Magpie Muffin 4 Pack (Thanksgiving)

This 4 pack gluten-free muffin assortment is perfect for holiday guests, featuring two Blueberry, one Banana Nutella, and one Raspberry Chia muffin. Flavor substitutions are available upon request.

Thanksgiving Decorated Layer Cake - 7"

Celebrate with our Thanksgiving Decorated Layer Cake, a stunning 7" centerpiece for your holiday table. This cake is beautifully adorned with festive decorations, making it as delightful to look at as it is to eat.

Thanksgiving Decorated Cupcakes, 6 pack

Delight in our Thanksgiving Decorated Cupcakes, a 6-pack of festive treats. Each cupcake is beautifully adorned with holiday-themed decorations, making them perfect for your Thanksgiving celebration!

Bakery Items

Our bakery products are crafted with care and the finest ingredients, offering a wide variety of treats to satisfy every craving. From bread and flaky pastries to indulgent cookies, donuts, and cakes, each item is made to delight. Whether you're looking for a simple snack, a dessert to share, or something special for an event, our bakery selection brings the warmth of artisanal baking to your table.

Brownie - Chocolate Chip

Brownie - Walnut

Crumb Cake Classic

Crumb Cake Rasperry

Crumb Cake Blueberry

Crumb Cake Apple

Muffin, Blueberry

Muffin, Chocolate Chip

Muffin, Cranberry Walnut

Muffin, (VG) Morning Glory

Muffin, (GF) Banana Nutella

Muffin, (GF) Raspberry Chia

Mixed Berry Bread Pudding

Sticky Maple Pecan Bread Pudding

Scone Blueberry

Scone Chocolate Chip

Scone Orange Cranberry

Scone Laveder Chai

Chocolate Chip Whoopi Cookie

Snickerdoodle Whoopie with Maple Marshmallow Filling.

Oatmeal Whoopi Cookie

Lintzer Tart Cookies

White cake dipped in a creamy chocolate and rolled in coconut!

Cookie, Black & White

Very Berry Bars

Carrot Cake Wedge

Cheesecake Wedge

Vegan & Gluten Free, Frosted Cinnamon Spice Cake Wedge

Vegan & Gluten Free, Frosted Chocolate Cake Wedge

Seasonal Whoopie with Marshmallow Buttercream.

Personal Custard Tart - 4"

Pastry Items

Our bakery pastries are crafted with the finest ingredients and a passion for quality. Each item is freshly baked to offer a delightful array of flavors and textures, from buttery croissants and flaky turnovers to indulgent cinnamon rolls and fruit-filled treats. Perfect for any occasion, our pastries are beautifully presented and made to impress. Treat yourself or your guests to a taste of artisanal goodness!

Plain Croissant

Chocolate Croissant

Almond Turnover

Cherry Yogurt Danish

Raspberry Cruffin

Leek & Parmesan Pastry

Tomato Olive Pastry

Ground pork, bacon, celery, egg, garlic, caramelized onions and our Magpie spices! (It's not spicy, but its packed with flavor!)

Bacon, Egg & Cheese Stuffed Croissant

Egg & Cheese Stuffed Croissant

Donuts

Our bakery donuts are a delicious blend of classic flavors and creative twists, all freshly made and perfectly fluffy. From traditional glazed and powdered donuts to gourmet options with unique toppings and fillings, there's something for every donut lover. Each donut is crafted to deliver a satisfying bite that’s just the right balance of sweetness and texture. Perfect for breakfast, a midday treat, or any special occasion!

Small Coffee & Donut Special (Mon-Thurs until 10am)

Available Tuesday-Thursday 7am-10am.

Donut, Strawberry Frosted

Donut, Vanilla Frosted

Donut, Chocolate Frosted

Donut, Blueberry Frosted

Donut, Jelly Filled

Donut, Strawberry Cream Filled

Donut, Apple Crumb Filled

Donut, Blueberry Lemon Filled

Donut, Boston Cream Filled

Donut, Chocolate Cream Filled

Half Dozen Specialty Donuts

Please allow us one to two hours to prepare your goodies!

Dozen Specialty Donuts

Please allow us one to two hours to prepare your goodies!

Box Of Brew & Dozen Donuts

Please allow us one to two hours to prepare your goodies!

Boston Cream Donut

Donut, Fruity Strawberry Pebbles (Filled)

Cakes & Cupcakes

Enhance your celebration with a delicious cake or cupcakes from The Magpie Bakery! For Two-tier, 1/4 Sheet & 1/2 Sheet cakes, we require a minimum of 48 hours notice to ensure product quality. For any questions, please don't hesitate to call us!

We can make your vision come to life! See our social pages on IG and FB for some of our beautiful cake creations. In addition we have Gluten Free and Dairy Free Cakes available for pre-order down below. Special decoration and fillings are an additional charge.

Red Velvet Cakes

Our Red Velvet is decadent and rich. We can make it with Vanilla or Cream Cheese frosting! We require a minimum of 2 days notice to ensure product quality.

Choose your size with our scrumptious Carrot Cake! Contains both Raisins and Walnuts. For special requests please indicate or call us. We require a minimum of 2 days notice to ensure product quality.

Gluten Free Cakes

We require a minimum of 2 days notice to ensure product quality. The Carrot Cake has both Raisins and Walnuts! For special requests please indicate or call us.

We require a minimum of 2 days notice to ensure product quality. We can make our Chocolate Cake Vegan or GF! For special requests please indicate or call us.

Cheesecake 6" Medium

Cheesecake 8" (Thanksgiving)

Delight your holiday guests with our Thanksgiving Cheesecake, an 8" masterpiece that's perfect for any festive gathering!

Cheesecake 8" With Topping, please specify. (Thankgiving)

Enjoy our 8" Cheesecake topped with your choice of flavors. Perfect for Thanksgiving, this creamy delight can be customized to suit your taste—just specify your desired topping!

Cupcake Chocolate

Cupcake Vanilla

Cupcake (Special Design or Flavor)

Cupcake Red Velvet

Cupcake Vegan Or Gluten Free - Chocolate

Choco Cupcakes - Package of Six

Cake, Vanilla Cupcakes - Package of Six

Half & Half Cupcakes - Package of Six

5" Single Layer Cake

7" Single Layer Cake

7" Single Layer Oreo Cake

6" Red Velvet Single Layer Cake

5" Boston Cream Cake

7" Boston Cream Cake

5" Strawberry Shortcake

7" Strawberry Shortcake (10 - 12 Servings)

5" Black Forest Cake

7" Black Forest Cake

Strawberry Shortcake Parfait

Boston Cream Parfait

Parfait, Cookies & Cream

Mixed Berry Parfait

Banana Cream Parfait

Chocolate Cherry Parfait

Cake, Napoleon - small

Special Design Cupcake

Cupcake Special Design

Crumb Cake Apple Butter

Two Tier Cake 10" Bottom & 8" Top

Baked sweet merengue with whipped cream and mixed berries

Sweet Pies

Our sweet pies are made from scratch with fresh, quality ingredients and baked in our homemade flaky crust. Choose from our variety of flavors. Please allow us at least 2 hour to prepare your fresh pies!

Cherry Crumb Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Cherry Crumb Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings)

Apple Crumb Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Apple Crumb Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings)

Peach Raspberry Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Peach Raspberry Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings)

Apple Blueberry Crumb Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Apple Blueberry Crumb Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings)

Pie, Strawberry Rhubarb Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Pie, Strawberry Rhubarb Large 9" (6 - 8 Servings)

Pie, Cherry Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Pie, Classic Cherry Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings)

Pie, Blueberry Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Pie, Blueberry Large 9" (Thanksgiving)

Savor our Blueberry Large 9" Pie, a Thanksgiving favorite filled with juicy blueberries and a perfectly flaky crust. Ideal for your holiday feast!

Wildberry Crisp Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Pie, Chocolate Maple Pecan Pie Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Pie, Chocolate Maple Pecan Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings)

Lemon Meringue Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Lemon Meringue Large 9" (6 - 8 Servings)

Key Lime Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Key Lime Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings)

Pie, Cream Pie Banana 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Pie, Cream Pie Banana Large 9" (Thanksgiving)

Treat yourself to our Banana Cream Pie, a 9" Thanksgiving delight. Creamy banana filling in a flaky crust makes this pie a holiday favorite!

Pie, Cream Pie Chocolate Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Pie, Cream Pie Chocolate Large 9" (Thanksgiving)

Savor our Chocolate Cream Pie, a 9" Thanksgiving indulgence. Rich, creamy chocolate filling in a flaky crust makes this pie a holiday must-have!

Coconut Custard Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Coconut Custard Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings)

Wildberry Crisp 9" (Family style 6-7 servings)

Savory Pies

Try our delicious savory pies! Made from scratch savory fillings, in our home made flaky crust. In three convenient sizes, our sumptuous pies are sure to please. Please allow us at least 2 hour to prepare your fresh pies!

Pie, Chicken Pot Pie Hand Pie (Single Serving)

Looking for a delicious and easy-to-make chicken pot pie? Look no further than our Chicken Pot Pie Hand Pie! This delectable hand pie is made with all-natural, free-range chicken breast, potatoes, carrots, peas, and cream, all encased in a perfectly flaky pastry crust. Simply bake and enjoy! And they're portable too, so you can take them on-the-go. Our Chicken Pot Pie Hand Pie is sure to become a family favorite.

Pie, Chicken Pot Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Looking for a delicious and easy-to-make chicken pot pie? Look no further than our Chicken Pot Pie Pie! This delectable hand pie is made with all-natural, free-range chicken breast, potatoes, carrots, peas, and cream, with a perfectly flaky pastry crust. Simply bake and enjoy! Our Chicken Pot Pie Hand Pie is sure to become a family favorite.

Pie, Chicken Pot Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings)

Looking for a delicious and easy-to-make chicken pot pie? Look no further than our Chicken Pot Pie Pie! This delectable hand pie is made with all-natural, free-range chicken breast, potatoes, carrots, peas, and cream, with a perfectly flaky pastry crust. Simply bake and enjoy! Our Chicken Pot Pie Hand Pie is sure to become a family favorite.

Pie, Shepard's Hand Pie (Single Serving)

Introducing the new Shepards Pie Hand Pie! This delicious hand pie is perfect for any occasion. Made with freshly ground beef, vegetables, and spices, this hearty pie is sure to please. The flaky crust and savory filling will have you coming back for more. So, grab a slice of history and enjoy the traditional taste of Shepherd's Pie.

Pie, Pulled Pork Hand Pie (Single Serving)

The pork is roasted for 9 hours in our homemade BBQ sauce and spice rub! It is then mixed with caramelized onions for a flavorful combination in our flaky pastry.

Pulled Pork Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Pie, Mac & Cheese Hand Pie (Single Serving)

Pie, Mac & Cheese Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings)

Pie, Steak & Ale Hand Pie (Single Serving)

Steak & Ale Medium 6" (3 - 4 Servings

Steak & Ale Large 9" (Family Style, 6 - 7 Servings)

Pie, Summer Harvest Hand Pie

Pie, Super Bowl Six Pack Of Hand Pies

Beverages

Did you know we make excellent espresso drinks, chai and matcha lattes? We also brew our own signature iced teas, Lavender Vanilla and Mango Passionfruit, and Strawberry Elderflower are perfect for cooling off.

Equal parts espresso, steamed milk and foamed milk. Usually served straight up without any flavoring, but the foam is often sprinkled with powdered chocolate or cinnamon.

a coffee drink of Italian origin made with espresso and steamed milk.

café mocha is based on espresso and hot milk but with added chocolate flavouring and sweetener, typically in the form of cocoa powder and sugar. Whip cream is optional.

Hot Chai is a tea beverage made by boiling black tea in milk and water with a mixture of aromatic herbs and spices.

Hot Golden Milk Latte

a strong, concentrated coffee made by forcing pressurized water through finely ground coffee beans. Served in a small cup called a demitasse, and meant to be taken quickly, like a shot.

A cortado is a beverage consisting of espresso mixed with a roughly equal amount of warm milk to reduce the acidity. The milk in a cortado is steamed, but not frothy and "texturized" as in many Italian coffee drinks.

sometimes called espresso macchiato, is an espresso coffee drink with a small amount of milk, usually foamed. In Italian, macchiato means "stained" or "spotted" so the literal translation of caffè macchiato is "stained” or “marked coffee.”

The Magpie Iced Tea

Holiday Beverage Special

Seasonal Chia Special

Platters/Trays Of Cookies

For our trays or platters, we require a minimum of 48 hours notice to ensure product quality. For any questions, please don't hesitate to call us!

Cookie, Chocolate Chip Cookie Pack (6 Cookies)

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie with White Chocolate Drizzle Pack (6 Cookies)

Italian Sprinkle Cookies (6 Pack)

Pumpkin Cookie Pack (Pack of Six)

Cookie, Italian Rainbow (10 pieces)

Magpie Cookie Platter (3 Oatmeal Raisin, 3 Choc Chip, 4 Italian Rainbow, and 3 Cute Sugar Cookie

Crumb Cake Tray 8x8- Classic

Crumbcake Tray 8x8 - Fruit (Raspberry or Blueberry)

Cookie, Sugar Cookie Pack (6 Cookies)

Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies (6 Cookies)

Cookie, Double Chocolate Shortbread (6 Cookies)

Gingerbread Men (Decorated 6" Cookie)

Artisan Breads And Rolls

Call 30 min in advance for hot oven fresh bread, or pick up frozen for on the run.

Bread, Baguette

Asagio Cheese and Red Pepper Flake Loaf

Bread, Challa Loaf

Merchandise

Groupon

Groupon 2 Large Savory Pies for $52.50

Your cart is empty.